以证据为基础的补充和替代医学

评论文章

瑜伽和癌症的干预措施:回顾病人报告结果的临床意义癌症幸存者

表2

(一)HRQL Measures-Control DesignTable。(b)心理Measures-Control设计。(c)症状Measures-Control设计。(d) HRQL Measures-Single组设计。(e)心理Measures-Single组设计。(f)症状Measures-Single组设计。

(一)


研究	结果测量	内部一致性 (克伦巴赫α)	扫描电镜(基线SD×√1−克伦巴赫α)		基线0.5 SD		基线的意思(SD)		群体内部的意思差异(95%置信区间)		群体内部效应”Size-Hedges g (95%置信区间)		团体之间平均差 (95%置信区间)	团体之间效应”size-Hedges g(95%置信区间)
研究	结果测量	内部一致性 (克伦巴赫α)	瑜伽	控制	瑜伽	控制	瑜伽	控制	瑜伽	控制	瑜伽	控制

Chandwani et al。,2010年(10]	SF36电脑						41.50	41.8	1.60	−2.80	0.18	−0.27	4.40	0.46
	(物理)	.90	2.60	3.40	4.10	5.30	(8.20)	(10.6)	(−1.74,4.94)	(−6.35,0.75)	(−0.19,0.54)	(−0.62,0.08)	(−0.52,9.32)^c	(−0.06,0.97)
	SF36 MCS						47.80	48.0	1.90	1.90	0.17	0.18	0.00	0.00
	(心理)	.90	3.80	3.50	6.00	5.60	(12.00)	(11.1)	(−2.16,5.96)	(−1.76,5.56)	(−0.19,0.54)	(−0.17,0.52)	(−5.45,5.45)	(−0.51,0.51)

Culos-Reed et al ., 2006 (12]	EORTC-QoL						64.58	62.04	13.66	0.46	0.56	0.03	13.20	0.67
	(整体)	.89	8.50	4.26	12.82	6.43	(25.63)	(12.85)	[2.85,24.47]^ab	(−6.16,7.08)	[0.08,1.04]*	(−0.41,0.47)	[0.52,25.88]^cd	[0.01,1.32]*
	EORTC-Emo						79.58	75.00	4.22	−4.17	0.23	−0.25	8.39	0.48
	(情感)	.80	9.01	6.64	10.07	7.43	(20.14)	(14.85)	(−4.05,12.49)	(−11.57,3.23)	(−0.22,0.67)	(−0.70,0.20)	(−2.71,19.49)^cd	(−0.16,1.13)

Danhauer et al。,2009年 (13]	FACT-B						104.90	101.1	9.90	−2.70	0.48	−0.09	12.6	0.49
	(整体)	.90	6.30	7.70	10.00	12.20	(19.90)	(24.4)	(−0.71,20.51)^一个	(−17.80,12.40)	(−0.06,1.02)	(−0.58,0.41)	(−6.12,31.32)^cd	(−0.25,1.24)
	FACT-SWB						23.30	21.4	−0.20	−1.00	−0.04	−0.15	0.80	0.14
	(社会)	i =	2.60	3.00	2.60	2.70	(4.70)	(5.4)	(−2.84,2.44)	(−4.26,2.26)	(−0.55,0.47)	(−0.65,0.35)	(−3.43,5.03)	(−0.60,0.87)
	FACT-FWB						18.70	18.0	3.20	−0.60	0.57	−0.08	3.80	0.58
	(功能)	.86	2.60	3.10	2.90	3.50	(5.70)	(6.9)	[0.33,6.07]^ab	(−4.38,3.18)	[0.01,1.12]*	(−0.57,0.42)	(−1.00,8.60)^cd	(−0.17,1.34)
	FACT-EWB						18.10	18.5	2.70	−0.30	0.70	−0.05	3.00	0.61
	(情感)	i =	2.00	2.70	2.00	2.60	(3.90)	(5.2)	[0.74,4.66]^ab	(−3.29,2.69)	[0.13,1.28]*	(−0.54,0.44)	(−0.63,6.63)^cd	(−0.15,1.35)
	FACT-PWB						19.70	20.7	2.80	0.40	0.36	0.07	2.40	0.36
	(物理)	结果	3.00	2.20	3.50	2.60	(7.00)	(5.1)	(−1.18,6.78)	(−2.44,3.24)	(−0.17,0.89)	(−0.42,0.56)	(−2.44,7.24)^c	(−0.38,1.10)
	SF-12电脑						42.70	40.6	2.10	2.10	0.16	0.18	0.00	0.00
	(物理)	.86	4.50	3.80	6.1 0	5.10	(12.10)	(10.1)	(−4.56,8.76)	(−3.68,7.88)	(−0.35,0.67)	(−0.32,0.68)	(−8.79,8.79)	(−0.73.0.73]
	SF-12 MCS						43.40	49.9	8.80	−2.40	0.93	−0.18	11.20	1.00
	(心理)	结果	4.40	4.50	5.10	5.10	(10.10)	(10.2)	[3.97,13.63]^ab	(−8.90,4.10)	[0.30,1.55]* *	(−0.68,0.31)	[3.01,19.39]^cd	[0.22,1.78]* *

利特曼等。,2011年 (14]	FACT-B						89.00	87.8	1.30	−0.10	0.12	−0.01	1.40	0.11
	(整体)	.90	2.97	4.49	4.70	7.10	(9.40)	(14.2)	(−2.58,5.18)	(−5.61,5.41)	(−0.24,0.49)	(−0.37,0.36)	(−5.34,8.14)	(−0.42,0.64)
	FACT-SWB						21.70	21.7	0.40	−0.80	0.08	−0.14	1.20	0.22
	(社会)	i =	2.84	3.01	2.60	2.70	(5.10)	(5.4)	(−1.51,2.31)	(−2.96,1.40)	(−0.29,0.44)	(−0.50,0.23)	(−1.68,4.08)	(−0.31,0.75)
	FACT-FWB						22.70	21.6	−0.10	0.10	−0.03	0.02	0.20	0.05
	(功能)	.86	1.23	1.46	1.70	2.60	(3.30)	(5.1)	(−1.47,1.27)	(−1.75,1.95)	(−0.39,0.34)	(−0.35,0.39)	(−2.11,2.51)	(−0.50,0.57)
	FACT-EWB						19.80	20.3	0.50	0.50	0.14	0.17	0.00	0.00
	(情感)	i =	1.56	1.45	1.40	1.30	(2.80)	(2.6)	(−0.84,1.84)	(−0.59,1.59)	(−0.23,0.51)	(−0.20,0.54)	(−1.73,1.73)	(−0.53−0.53)
	FACT-PWB						24.70	24.2	0.70	0.10	0.33	0.02	0.60	0.18
	(物理)	结果	1.00	1.7 0	1.20	2.00	(2.30)	(3.9)	(−0.08,1.48)	(−1.47,1.67)	(−0.05,0.71)	(−0.34,0.39)	(−1.16,2.36)	(−0.35,0.71)

Moadel et al。,2007年 (15]	FACT-G						76.53	77.54	1.54	−7.16	0.09	−0.30	8.70	0.43
	(整体)	.89	5.96	8.11	8.99	12.23	(17.98)	(24.45)	(−3.60,6.68)	(−16.25,1.93)	(−0.20,0.37)	(−0.68,0.09)	(−0.96,18.36)^c	(−0.05,0.91)
	FACT-SWB						20.98	22.12	−0.30	−3.95	−0.05	−0.60	3.65	0.60
	(社会)	i =	3.47	3.46	3.12	3.11	(6.23)	(6.22)	(−1.99,1.39)	(−6.41−1.49)^ab	(−0.34,0.24)	(−1.00−0.19)* *	[0.75,6.56]^cd	[0.11,1.09]*
	FACT-FWB						18.33	18.19	−0.16	−1.98	−0.02	−0.26	1.82	0.26
	(功能)	.80	2.85	3.45	3.19	3.86	(6.38)	(7.72)	(−2.08,1.76)	(−4.88,0.92)	(−0.31,0.26)	(−0.63,0.12)	(−1.53,5.17)	(−0.22,0.74)
	FACT-EWB						16.36	16.50	1.83	−0.41	0.40	−0.07	2.24	0.44
	(情感)	.74点	2.43	3.03	2.39	2.97	(4.77)	(5.94)	[0.51,3.14]* *	(−2.65,1.83)	[0.10,0.70]* *	[0.44,0.31]	(−0.19,4.67)	(−0.05,0.92)
	FACT-PWB						20.87	20.73	0.16	−0.82	0.03	−0.12	0.98	0.16
	(物理)	总共花掉	2.24	2.98	2.64	3.52	(5.28)	(7.03)	(−1.51,1.83)	(−3.39,1.75)	(−0.26,0.32)	(−0.49,0.26)	(−1.96,3.91)	(−0.32,0.64)

Vadiraja et al。,2009年 (16]	EORTC-Phys						73.20	62.72	0.06	6.24	0.00	0.20	6.18	0.23
	(物理)	点	12.49	16.68	11.60	15.49	(23.20)	(30.98)	(−7.30,7.42)	(−4.19,16.66)	(−0.29,0.30)	(−0.14,0.54)	(−6.24,18.60)	(−0.23,0.68)
	EORTC-Role						72.72	71.59	7.16	1.26	0.20	0.03	5.90	0.16
	(作用)	点	24.15	25.22	17.43	18.20	(34.86)	(36.40)	(−3.32,17.64)	(−11.81,14.33)	(−0.10,0.50)	(−0.30,0.37)	(−10.64,22.44)	(−0.29,0.61)
	EORTC-Emo (情感)						56.45	51.58	18.67	7.65	0.89	0.36	11.02	0.53
	EORTC-Emo (情感)	.80	8.84	7.80	9.89	8.72	(19.77)	(17.44)	[12.47,24.87]^ab	[0.48,14.82]	[0.54,1.25]* * *	(−0.01,0.70)*	[1.57,20.47]^cd	[0.07,0.99]*
	EORTC-Cog						85.29	82.67	5.28	−1.90	0.30	−0.08	7.18	0.36
	(认知)	收	9.35	10.97	9.00	10.56	(18.00)	(21.12)	[0.13,10.43]	(−9.66,5.86)	[0.00,0.61]*	(−0.42,0.25)	(−1.83,16.19)	(−0.10,0.82)
	EORTC-Soc						52.82	52.41	2.14	−2.48	0.08	−0.10	4.62	0.18
	(社会)	.77点	12.73	11.72	13.28	12.22	(26.55)	(24.43)	(−5.53,9.81)	(−10.78,5.82)	(−0.22,0.38)	(−0.43,0.23)	(−6.74,15.98)	(−0.27,0.64)

(b)

研究

结果测量

内部一致性(克伦巴赫α)

扫描电镜(基线SD×√1−克伦巴赫α)

基线0.5 SD

基线的意思(SD)

群体内部
平均差(95%置信区间)

群体内部
效应”Size-Hedges g(95%置信区间)

团体之间
平均差(95%置信区间)

团体之间
效应”size-Hedges g(95%置信区间)

瑜伽

控制

瑜伽

控制

瑜伽

控制

瑜伽

控制

瑜伽

控制

Chandwani et al。,2010年(10]

鉴定20

11.60

10.50

−5.00

−3.50

−0.48

−0.32

−1.50

−0.14

(抑郁症)

.87点

3.35

2.42

4.65

3.35

(9.30)

(6.70)

(−8.85−1.15)^ab

(−7.23,0.24)^一个

(−0.86−0.09)*

(−0.67,0.03)

(−6.87,3.87)

(−0.65,0.37)

STAI-State

36.30

32.70

−8.30

−2.50

−0.63

−0.20

−5.80

−0.46

(焦虑)

总收入

3.36

2.45

6.85

5.00

(13.70)

(10.00)

(−13.09−3.51)^ab

(−6.75,1.75)^一个

(−1.04−0.23)* *

(−0.55,0.15)

(−12.18,0.58)^cd

(−0.98,0.05)

科恩
et al。,2004年(11]

鉴定20

10.20

9.60

−1.20

.10

−0.12

0.01

−1.30

−0.15

(抑郁症)

公布

2.91

2.27

5.50

4.29

(11.00)

(8.57)

(−5.91,3.51)

(−3.79,4.00)

(−0.58,0.35)

(−0.48,0.51)

(−7.52,4.92)

(−0.85,0.55)

STAI-State

34.30

37.80

−0.20

−4.00

−0.02

−0.30

−3.80

−0.31

(焦虑)

.95

2.75

3.26

6.15

7.30

(12.30)

(14.60)

(−5.54,5.14)

(−10.65,2.65)^一个

(−0.48,0.45)

(−0.80,0.21)

(−12.24,4.64)^c

(−1.02,0.39)

Culos-Reed et al。,2006年(12]

POMS-D

4.70

5.44

−2.48

0.06

−0.34

0.01

−2.54

−0.39

(抑郁症)

.95

1.76

1.14

3.93

2.55

(7.86)

(5.10)

(−5.68,0.72)^一个

(−2.54,2.66)

(−0.80,0.11)

(−0.43,0.45)

(−6.66,1.58)^c

(−1.04,0.25)

Danhauer et al。,2009年(13]

鉴定20

16.30

16.60

−8.20

1.20

−0.82

0.07

−9.40

−0.69

(抑郁症)

公布

2.57

3.89

4.85

7.35

(9.70)

(14.70)

(−13.27−3.17)^ab

(−7.14,9.54)

(−1.42−0.22)* *

(−0.42,0.57)

(−19.34,0.54)^cd

(−1.45,0.06)

PANAS-P

32.70

30.60

5.50

1.20

0.64

0.11

4.30

0.45

(积极的影响)

.87点

3.17

3.53

4.40

4.90

(8.80)

(9.80)

[1.16,9.84]^ab

(−4.21,6.61)

[0.08,1.21]*

(−0.39,0.60)

(−2.71,11.31)^c

(−0.29,1.19)

PANAS-N

19.00

18.50

−5.00

1.40

−0.65

0.14

−6.40

−0.73

(负面影响)

.87点

2.99

3.39

4.15

4.70

(8.30)

(9.40)

(−8.91−1.09)^ab

(−3.63,6.43)

(−1.22,0.08)*

(−0.36,0.63)

(−12.84,0.04)^cd

(−1.49,0.03)

FACIT-Sp

23.30

23.20

2.70

−1.70

0.38

−0.19

4.40

0.56

(精神健康)

.87点

2.38

2.60

3.30

3.60

(6.60)

(7.20)

(−0.92,6.31)^一个

(−6.16,2.76)

(−0.15,0.91)

(−0.69,0.31)

(−1.40,10.20)^cd

(−0.19,1.30)

Moadel et al。,2007年(15]

FACIT-Sp

37.87

34.58

−1.02

−1.83

−0.11

−0.15

0.81

0.08

(精神健康)

.87点

3.33

3.99

4.62

5.53

(9.24)

(11.06)

(−3.59,1.55)

(−6.49,2.83)

(−0.40,0.17)

(−0.52,0.23)

(−4.08,5.70)

(−0.40,0.56)

Vadiraja et al。,2009年(16]

PANAS-P

24.05

21.81

3.80

1.52

0.52

0.19

2.28

0.30

(积极的影响)

.87点

2.62

2.66

3.64

3.69

(7.28)

(7.37)

[1.62,5.98]^ab

(−1.17,4.21)

[0.20,0.84]* * *

(−0.15,0.53)

(−1.14,5.70)

(−0.15,0.76)

PANAS-N

22.15

25.22

−9.24

−3.37

−0.86

−0.33

−5.87

−0.57

(负面影响)

.87点

3.82

3.18

5.30

4.41

(10.60)

(8.82)

(−12.41−6.074)^ab

(−6.78,0.04)^一个

(−1.21−0.51)* * *

(−0.67,0.01)

(−10.56−1.18)^cd

(−1.03−0.11)*

Vadiraja et al。,2009 b (17]

HADS-A

8.05

9.35

−3.17

−1.23

−0.86

−0.31

−1.94

−0.51

(焦虑)

.79

1.77

1.82

1.94

1.99

(3.87)

(3.98)

(−4.27−2.07)^ab

(−2.56,0.10)

(−1.21−0.51)* * *

(−0.65,0.03)

(−3.65−0.23)^c

(−0.97−0.05)*

HADS-D

7.57

8.00

−3.43

−1.47

−0.89

−0.40

−1.96

−0.52

(抑郁症)

.87点

1.45

1.25

2.01

1.74

(4.02)

(3.47)

(−4.57−2.29)^ab

(−2.71−0.23)^一个

(−1.25−0.54)* * *

(−0.74−0.05)*

(−3.65−0.27]。^cd

(−0.98−0.06)*

(c)


研究	结果测量	内部一致性(克伦巴赫α)	扫描电镜基线SD×√1−克伦巴赫的α)		基线SD 0.5		基线的意思(SD)		群体内部平均差(95%置信区间)		群体内部效应”size-Hedges g(95%置信区间)		团体之间平均差(95%置信区间)	团体之间效应”size-Hedges g(95%置信区间)
研究	结果测量	内部一致性(克伦巴赫α)	瑜伽	控制	瑜伽	控制	瑜伽	控制	瑜伽	控制	瑜伽	控制

Chandwani et al。,2010年(10]	BFI						2.30	2.30	−0.40	0.20	−0.12	0.05	−0.60	−0.17
	(疲劳)	总收入	0.39	0.54	0.80	1.10	(1.60)	(2.20)	(−1.58,0.78)^一个	(−1.17,1.57)	(−0.49,0.24)	(−0.29,0.39)	(−2.44,1.24)^c	(−0.68,0.34)
	PSQI						7.30	7.10	−0.70	−0.40	−0.15	−0.08	−0.30	−0.06
	(睡眠)	点	1.52	1.56	1.90	1.95	(3.80)	(3.90)	(−2.46,1.06)	(−2.15,1.35)	(−0.51,0.22)	(−0.42,0.27)	(−2.79,2.19)	(−0.57,0.45)

科恩 et al。,2004年(11]	BFI						3.10	2.80	0.00	0.30	0.00	0.15	−0.30	−0.14
	(疲劳)	.96点	0.48	0.44	1.20	1.10	(2.40)	(2.20)	(−1.03,1.03)	(−0.72,1.32)	(−0.47,0.47)	(−0.35,0.64)	(−1.76,1.16)	(−0.84,0.56)
	PSQI						6.50	7.20	−0.70	0.90	−0.16	0.21	−1.60	−0.37
	(睡眠)	点	2.00	1.88	2.50	2.35	(5.00)	(4.70)	(−2.82,1.42)	(−1.23,3.03)	(−0.62,0.32)	(−0.29,0.71)	(−4.62,1.42)	(−1.07,0.34)

Danhauer et al。,2009年(13]	事实- F						30.10	32.70	9.70	−0.10	0.72	−0.01	9.80	0.71
	(疲劳)	.95	3.00	2.64	6.70	5.90	(13.40)	(11.80)	[2.87,16.53]^ab	(−7.45,7.25)	[0.14,1.30]*	(−0.50,0.49)	(−0.27,19.87)^cd	(−0.04,1.47)
	PSQI						8.30	8.60	−2.20	−1.60	−0.46	−0.31	−0.60	−0.12
	(睡眠)	点	1.88	2.12	2.35	2.65	(4.70)	(5.30)	(−4.65,0.25)^一个	(−4.14,0.94)	(−1.00,0.08)	(−0.81,0.20)	(−4.14,2.94)	(−0.86,0.61)

利特曼等。,2011年(14]	FACT-F						43.10	43.20	1.9	−0.10	0.33	−0.01	2.00	0.25
利特曼等。,2011年(14]	(疲劳)	.95	1.30	1.90	2.90	4.25	(5.8)	(8.50)	(−0.20,4.00)^一个	(−3.69,3.49)	(−0.05,0.71)	(−0.38,0.36)	(−2.16,6.16)^c	(−0.27,0.78)

Moadel et al。,2007年(15]	FACT-F						34.27	35.88	2.29	−1.11	0.19	−0.08	3.40	0.27
Moadel et al。,2007年(15]	(疲劳)	.95	2.75	3.22	6.16	7.21	(12.31)	(14.42)	(−1.11,5.69)	(−6.50,4.30)	(−0.10,0.48)	(−0.45,0.30)	(−2.66,9.46)^c	(−0.21,0.75)

(d)


研究	结果测量	内部一致性 (克伦巴赫α)	扫描电镜(基线SD×√1−克伦巴赫的α)	基线0.5 SD	基线的意思(SD)	群体内部平均差(95%置信区间)	群体内部效应”Size-Hedges g(95%置信区间)

鲍尔等。,2011年(18]	SF36创健康				50.50	14.50	0.61
鲍尔等。,2011年(18]	(整体)	结果	9.63	11.05	(22.10)	[1.44,27.56]^ab	[0.00,1.21]*

Danhauer et al。,2008年(19]	FACT-G				75.90	3.50	0.32
	(整体)	.89	3.55	5.35	(10.70)	[0.33,6.67]	[0.02,0.63]*
	FACT-SWB				24.00	0.80	0.18
	(社会)	i =	2.39	2.15	(4.30)	(−0.53,2.13)	(−0.12,0.47)
	FACT-FWB				18.00	0.80	0.19
	(功能)	.80	1.92	2.15	(4.30)	(−0.44,2.04)	(−0.11,0.49)
	FACT-EWB				14.00	−0.20	−0.10
	(情感)	.74点	1.07	1.05	(2.10)	(−0.81,0.41)	(−0.39,0.20)
	FACT-PWB				20.00	2.10	0.38
	(物理)	总共花掉	2.42	2.85	(5.70)	[0.47,3.73]	[0.07,0.68]*
	SF12电脑				41.20	2.30	0.21
	(物理)	.86	4.27	5.70	(11.40)	(−0.98,5.58)	(−0.09,0.50)
	SF12 MCS				48.40	3.60	0.41
	(心理)	结果	3.75	4.30	(8.60)	[1.04,6.16]	[0.11,0.72]* *

邓肯et al。,2008年(20.]	FACT-G				64.6	10.63	0.69
邓肯et al。,2008年(20.]	(整体)	.89	4.70	7.30	(14.16)	[4.44,16.82]^ab	[0.24,1.14]* *

Galantino et al。,2011年(21]	FACT-B				89.33	16.72	0.81
Galantino et al。,2011年(21]	(整体)	.90	6.38	10.09	(20.18)	(−5.07,28.37)^ab	[0.14,1.48]*

Speed-Andrews et al。,2010年(22]	FACT-B				108.20	8.90	0.39
	(整体)	.90	6.67	10.55	(21.10)	(−1.51,19.31)^一个	(−0.08,0.86)
	FACT-SWB				20.70	0.70	0.13
	(社会)	i =	2.95	2.65	(5.30)	(−1.84,3.24)	(−0.33,0.58)
	FACT-FWB				19.90	1.80	0.39
	(功能)	.86	1.83	2.45	(4.90)	(−0.29,3.89)	(−0.08,0.86)
	FACT-EWB				15.80	2.10	0.39
	(情感)	i =	2.67	2.40	(4.80)	(−0.37,4.57)	(−0.09,0.86)
	FACT-PWB				20.90	2.00	0.38
	(物理)	结果	2.31	2.65	(5.30)	(−0.37,4.37)	(−0.09,0.85)
	SF-36电脑				45.50	3.70	0.32
	(物理)	.90	3.38	5.35	(10.70)	(−1.41,8.81)^一个	(−0.14,0.79)
	SF-36 MCS				44.40	4.20	0.45
	(心理)	.90	2.85	4.50	(9.00)	(−0.01,8.41)^一个	(−0.03,0.93)

Ulger Yağlı, 2010年(23]	NHP-Total				103.23	−17.32	−0.77
	(整体)	2	12.64	11.54	(23.08)	(−26.70−7.94)^ab	(−1.26−0.29)* *
	NHP-Social				43.01	−20.56	−0.74
	(社会)	56	20.01	15.08	(30.16)	(−32.24−8.88)^ab	(−1.22−0.26)* *
	NHP-Emotion				61.37	−26.61	−1.15
	(情感)	点	9.68	11.74	(23.47)	(−36.35−16.87)^ab	(−1.70−0.60)* * *
	NHP-Physical				44.51	−20.41	−0.92
	(物理)	开市	11.86	11.21	(22.41)	(−29.77−11.05)^ab	(−1.43−0.41)* * *

(e)


研究	结果测量	内部一致性 (克伦巴赫α)	扫描电镜(T1 SD×√1−克伦巴赫的α)	基线 0.5 SD	基线的意思(SD)	群体内部平均差(95%置信区间)	群体内部效应”Size-Hedges g(95%置信区间)

鲍尔等。,2011年(18]	BDI				15.40	−7.90	−1.00
鲍尔等。,2011年(18]	(抑郁症)	结果	3.49	4.00	(8.00)	(−12.20−3.60)^ab	(−1.69−0.32)* *

Danhauer et al。,2008年(19]	鉴定20				12.30	−3.10	−0.36
	(抑郁症)	公布	2.27	4.30	(8.60)	(−5.66−0.54)^一个	(−0.66−0.05)*
	STAI-State				34.20	−2.40	−0.22
	(焦虑)	.95	2.39	5.35	(10.70)	(−5.57,0.77)^一个	(−0.52,0.08)
	PANAS-P				34.70	1.50	0.17
	(积极的影响)	.87点	3.10	4.30	(8.60)	(−1.06,4.06)	(−0.12,0.47)
	PANAS-N				15.80	−1.70	−0.35
	(负面影响)	.87点	1.80	2.50	(5.00)	(−3.14−0.26)	(−0.65−0.04)*
	FACIT-Sp				38.70	1.40	0.19
	(精神健康)	.87点	2.56	3.55	(7.10)	(−0.74,3.54)	(−0.10,0.49)

邓肯et al。,2008年(20.]	FACIT-Sp				30.83	5.88	0.60
邓肯et al。,2008年(20.]	(精神健康)	.87点	3.65	5.07	(10.13)	[1.93,9.83]^ab	[0.16,1.04]* *

Speed-Andrews et al。,2010年(22]	鉴定10				31.00	−0.20	−0.34
	(抑郁症)	.85	0.23	0.30	(0.60)	(−0.47,0.07)	(−0.81,0.13)
	STAI-State				45.20	1.80	0.25
	(焦虑)	.85	2.59	3.35	(6.70)	(−1.48,5.08)	(−0.21,0.71)

Ulger Yağlı, 2010年(23]	STAI-State				55.05	−11.70	−1.51
Ulger Yağlı, 2010年(23]	(焦虑)	.95	1.75	3.92	(7.83)	(−14.96−8.44)^ab	(−2.14−0.88)* * *

(f)


研究	结果测量	内部一致性(克伦巴赫α)	扫描电镜(基线SD×√1−克伦巴赫的α)	基线0.5 SD	基线的意思(SD)	群体内部平均差(95%置信区间)	群体内部效应”Size-Hedges g(95%置信区间)

鲍尔等。,2011年(18]	FSI平均				6.3	−3.6	−2.34
	(疲劳)	.97点	0.19	0.55	(1.1)	(−4.44−2.76)^ab	(−3.47−1.22)* * *
	PSQI				7.1	−0.7	−0.17
	(睡眠)	点	1.64	2.05	(4.1)	(−2.99,1.59)	(−0.72,0.38)

Danhauer et al。,2008年(19]	FACT-F				34.6	2.7	0.22
Danhauer et al。,2008年(19]	(疲劳)	.95	2.71	6.05	(12.1)	(−0.83,6.27)^一个	(−0.08,0.52)

Ulger Yağlı,201023]	NHP-S				43.50	−23.47	−0.88
Ulger Yağlı,201023]	(睡眠)	开市	15.64	14.78	(29.55)	(−34.69−12.25)^ab	(−1.38−0.38)* * *

*,* *,* * *(报告之间的组值)。
^一个类内平均差超过1 SEM。
^b类内平均差超过基线0.5 SD。
^c群体间的平均超过对照组1 SEM。
^d群体间的平均超过对照组基线0.5 SD。
的缩写,α:α;SD:标准差;置信区间:置信区间;SF-36 SF-12:医学研究结果不仅健康调查;EORTC QLQ C30:欧洲组织生活Cancer-Quality C30的研究和治疗;FACT-B:癌症Therapy-Breast功能评估;FACT-G:癌症Therapy-General功能评估;额定马力:诺丁汉健康状况;BDI:贝克抑郁量表;鉴定20:流行病学研究中心抑郁Scale-20项目; STAI: State/Trait Anxiety Inventory; POMS: Profile of Mood States; PANAS: Positive and Negative Affect Schedule; FACIT-Sp: Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy-Spiritual Well-Being; HADS: Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale; BFI: Brief Fatigue Inventory; FSI: Fatigue Symptom Inventory; PSQI: Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index; FACT-F: Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-Fatigue.