研究文章

多尺度合作微分进化算法

表4

比较结果与玉MCDE, java开发环境,萨德,EPSDE代码,CoBiDE (D= 50)。

函数 智能手机 萨德 EPSDE 代码 CoBiDE LSHADE MCDE

F1 0.00E+ 00±0.00E+ 00≈ 0.00E+ 00±0.00E+ 00≈ 0.00E+ 00±0.00E+ 00≈ 5.25E−29±1.28E−−28日 8.07E−30±4.04E−−29日 0.00E+ 00±0.00E+ 00≈ 0.00E+ 00±0.00E+ 00≈ 0.00E+ 00±0.00E+ 00
F2 3.57E−27±1.67E−27 + 2.22E−02±3.21E−02− 6.55E−02±4.34E−02− 5.77E−23±8.87E−23 + 5.87E−09±6.51E09年−− 1.03E−06±1.08E06年−− 6.85E−27±7.92E−27 + 5.76E−13±1.01E−12
F3 1.41E+ 05±6.61E+ 03− 4.48E+ 05±2.21E+ 05− 8.01E+ 05±5.44E+ 05− 7.82E+ 06±1.35E+ 7− 3.22E+ 05±8.66E+ 04− 2.31E+ 05±7.87E+ 04− 1.97E+ 04±1.07E+ 04 + 4.31E+ 04±3.02E+ 04
F4 2.79E+ 00±1.26E+ 1− 3.88E+ 02±3.13E+ 2− 7.28E+ 02±4.56E+ 2− 3.42E+ 03±3.51E+ 04− 4.98E+ 02±5.78E+ 2− 1.52E+ 02±9.61E+ 1− 2.24E+ 01±5.73E+ 1− 8.51E−01±8.82E−1
F5 1.45E+ 03±4.38E+ 2− 3.65E+ 03±6.29E+ 2− 8.34E+ 03±1.29E+ 03− 4.66E+ 03±8.85E+ 2− 3.60E+ 03±5.69E+ 2− 2.71E+ 03±6.16E+ 2− 1.12E+ 03±4.72E+ 2− 2.09E+ 02±4.11E+ 2
F6 7.71E+ 00±3.03E+ 1− 4.43E+ 02±2.78E+ 1− 4.39E+ 02±2.52E+ 1− 1.43E+ 02±1.95E+ 00− 1.23E+ 02±2.12E+ 00− 2.36E+ 01±1.88E+ 1− 7.37E−01±1.49E+ 00− 7.21E−01±1.46E+ 00
F7 7.57E−03±1.09E−02− 2.85E−03±6.10E−03 + 9.23E−03±5.45E−02− 1.08E−02±1.79E−02− 6.54E−03±9.36E−−3日 4.01E−03±3.09E−−3日 2.16E−03±4.04E−03 + 3.05E−03±6.32E−03
F8 2.11E+ 01±5.93E−02≈ 2.11E+ 01±3.72E−02≈ 2.11E+ 01±4.33E−02≈ 2.11E+ 01±3.35E−02≈ 2.01E+ 01±1.09E−1 + 2.08E+ 01±4.45E−1 + 2.07E+ 01±2.89E−1 + 2.11E+ 01±5.06E−02
F9 0.00E+ 00±0.00E+ 00 + 0.00E+ 00±0.00E+ 00 + 9.94E−01±2.21E01−− 6.39E−16±1.01E−15 + 2.38E+ 00±4.33E01−− 3.21E−13±9.03E−13 + 7.11E−17±3.55E−16 + 9.55E−01±2.92E+ 00
F10 6.55E+ 01±6.93E+ 00− 9.98E+ 01±1.32E+ 1− 1.14E+ 02±1.54E+ 1− 1.54E+ 02±2.53E+ 1− 8.29E+ 01±1.93E+ 1− 9.24E+ 01±2.04E+ 1− 4.60E+ 01±5.30E+ 00− 4.31E+ 01±1.15E+ 01
F11 5.24E+ 01±2.15E+ 00− 5.42E+ 01±2.10E+ 00− 4.45E+ 01±1.89E+ 00− 7.04E+ 01±3.21E+ 00− 3.14E+ 01±5.35E+ 00− 1.80E+ 01±4.49E+ 00 + 5.39E+ 01±3.26E+ 00− 3.03E+ 01±8.38E+ 00
F12 1.54E+ 04±1.27E+ 04− 1.57E+ 04±1.54E+ 04− 5.65E+ 04±2.04E+ 04− 3.16E+ 05±3.85E+ 04− 1.54E+ 04±1.73E+ 04− 1.35E+ 04±1.22E+ 04− 1.21E+ 04±1.04E+ 04− 1.16E+ 04±1.01E+ 04
F13 2.78E+ 00±1.99E01−− 2.94E+ 00±2.41E01−− 7.27E+ 00±7.34E01−− 6.17E+ 00±6.03E01−− 3.23E+ 00±4.15E01−− 4.28E+ 00±1.32E+ 00− 2.14E+ 00±1.03E−1 + 2.72E+ 00±4.54E−1
F14 2.16E+ 01±4.76E01−− 2.25E+ 01±2.26E01−− 2.23E+ 01±2.42E01−− 2.34E+ 01±2.63E01−− 2.19E+ 01±4.39E01−− 2.20E+ 01±3.87E01−− 2.18E+ 01±3.12E01−− 2.12E+ 01±3.24E−1
F15 3.77E+ 02±9.03E+ 1− 3.62E+ 02±1.21E+ 2 + 3.86E+ 02±7.62E+ 1− 2.64E+ 02±6.45E+ 1 + 3.88E+ 02±6.00E+ 1− 3.92E+ 02±4.00E+ 1− 2.97E+ 02±9.67E+ 1 + 3.68E+ 02±6.23E+ 01
F16 8.42E+ 01±7.92E+ 1− 8.35E+ 01±1.03E+ 1− 8.78E+ 01±6.57E+ 1− 1.50E+ 02±4.25E+ 1− 9.35E+ 01±7.01E+ 1− 7.64E+ 01±2.11E+ 1− 9.82E+ 2 + 02−±1.35 7.56E+ 01±1.01E+ 2
F17 9.39E+ 01±2.64E+ 1− 1.81E+ 02±2.31E+ 1− 9.81E+ 01±1.01E+ 2− 2.38E+ 02±7.01E+ 1− 7.21E+ 01±2.58E+ 1 + 7.62E+ 01±1.73E+ 1 + 1.18E+ 02±1.08E+ 2− 8.84E+ 01±1.26E+ 2
F18 9.21E+ 02±4.38E+ 00− 9.20E+ 02±3.35E+ 00− 9.78E+ 02±8.37E+ 1− 8.53E+ 02±2.42E+ 1 + 9.21E+ 02±5.42E+ 00− 9.12E+ 02±2.39E+ 01≈ 9.18E+ 02±4.25E+ 00− 9.14E+ 02±9.46E+ 00
F19 9.19E+ 02±1.07E+ 1− 9.20E+ 02±2.88E+ 00− 9.78E+ 02±7.81E+ 1− 8.59E+ 02±1.54E+ 1 + 9.21E+ 02±4.64E+ 00− 9.14E+ 02±2.39E+ 01≈ 9.18E+ 02±6.62E+ 00− 9.15E+ 02±2.90E+ 00
F20. 9.21E+ 02±3.38E+ 00− 9.20E+ 02±3.14E+ 00− 9.55E+ 02±3.54E+ 1− 8.56E+ 02±3.03E+ 00 + 9.11E+ 02±3.38E+ 1− 9.18E+ 02±3.40E+ 00≈ 9.17E+ 02±7.36E+ 00≈ 9.16E+ 02±3.94E+ 00
F21 5.52E+ 02±1.49E+ 2 + 7.21E+ 02±2.55E+ 2− 5.66E+ 02±2.32E+ 2 + 7.29E+ 02±2.82E+ 00− 6.83E+ 02±2.49E+ 2− 5.40E+ 02±1.41E+ 2 + 6.82E+ 02±2.48E+ 2− 6.21E+ 02±2.21E+ 2
F22 9.05E+ 02±2.48E+ 1− 9.05E+ 02±1.23E+ 00− 9.82E+ 02±8.21E+ 1− 5.00E+ 02±6.61E−2 + 9.01E+ 02±2.18E+ 1− 8.84E+ 02±2.53E+ 1 + 8.97E+ 02±1.94E+ 01≈ 8.97E+ 02±1.65E+ 01
F23 5.82E+ 02±1.31E+ 2 + 8.60E+ 02±2.25E+ 2− 5.98E+ 02±7.29E+ 00 + 7.33E+ 02±4.48E+ 00− 7.10E+ 02±2.33E+ 2− 6.91E+ 02±2.25E+ 02≈ 8.04E+ 02±2.40E+ 2− 6.90E+ 02±2.25E+ 2
F24 2.00E+ 02±1.49E−12≈ 2.00E+ 02±1.62E−12≈ 2.89E+ 02±6.55E+ 1− 2.38E+ 02±1.34E+ 1− 2.00E+ 02±5.81E−14≈ 2.00E+ 02±1.08E−12≈ 2.32E+ 02±1.57E+ 2− 2.00E+ 02±1.66E−12
F25 2.18E+ 02±1.71E+ 00− 2.16E+ 02±1.41E+ 00− 2.24E+ 02±1.25E+ 1− 2.47E+ 02±1.87E+ 1− 2.17E+ 02±1.97E+ 00− 2.15E+ 02±1.46E+ 00− 2.18E+ 02±1.69E+ 00− 2.14E+ 02±7.36E−1
18/4/3 20/2/3 21/2/2 17/7/1 22/2/1 13/6/6 15/7/3