研究文章

数字图像水印技术通过混合方法的分析

表3

SSIM PSNR,误码率、美和数控值在1型攻击。

计划 测试图像 直方图均衡化 高斯噪声 满头花白的噪音 LPGF JPEG压缩(QF) JPEG 2000 (CR) 裁剪(%) 旋转(°)

DWT-DCT [3] 丽娜 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - SSIM = 0.9839 (QF = 50%) - - - - - - SSIM = 0.9495 (25%) - - - - - -
DWT-SVD [4] 丽娜 数控= 1.0 数控= 1.0(比例因子= 0.99) 数控= 1.0(比例因子= 0.99) - - - - - - 数控= 0.7593 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
DWT-SVD [5] 摄影师 - - - - - - PSNR值= 20.4017(比例因子= 0.01) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - PSNR值= 7.8166 - - - - - -
DWT-SVD [7] Goldhill PSNR值= 17.545(比例因子,μ= 5) PSNR值= 30.000(比例因子,μ= 5) PSNR值= 12.364(比例因子,μ= 5) PSNR值= 29.794(比例因子,μ= 5) PSNR值= 8.356(比例因子,μ= 5) - - - - - - PSNR值= 13.047(比例因子,μ= 5) PSNR值= 11.430(200)(比例因子,μ= 5)
DWT-DCT [8] 进行核磁共振成像的大脑 数控= 0.7498 数控= 0.9487 (μ= 0,var = 0.00001) 数控= 0.9850(噪声级= 0.001) 数控= 0.7779 数控= 1.0000 (QF = 65) - - - - - - 数控= 0.6963 数控= 0.6981 (0.01°)
DCT-DWT [9] 辣椒 数控= 0.9739 数控= 0.9413(噪音水平= 10%) - - - - - - 数控= 0.9926 (QF = 100) - - - - - - 数控= 0.9594 (154×154) 数控= 0.9886 (75°)
DWT-DCT [10] 丽娜 - - - - - - 数量= 5.67 (var = 0.001) 数量= 14.44(强度= 1%) 数量= 0.04 (3×3) 数量= 0.02 (QF = 80) 数量= 0.01 (CR = 2) 数量= 11.99 (25%) 数量= 13.94 (45°)
SVD-DCT [11] 的脸 美= 25.449 美= 0.068 - - - - - - - - - - - - 美= 1.346 (QF = 100) - - - - - - 美= 11.462(在角落种植32×32) - - - - - -
DWT-DCT-SVD [12] 腹部 - - - - - - 数控= 0.9999(0.8比例因子μ= 0,var = 0.01) 数控= 0.9999 0.8比例因子(密度= 0.01) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
LWT-DCT-SVD [13] 丽娜 PSNR值= 45.01206 PSNR值= 43.96941 (μ= 0,var = 0.001) PSNR值= 44.05564(密度= 0.02) PSNR值= 44.88039 (3×3) PSNR值= 43.86933 (QF = 70%) - - - - - - PSNR值= 44.97377 (25%) PSNR值= 44.82333 (5°)
DCT-SVD [14] 芭芭拉 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 数控= 0.9952 数控= 0.9952
DFT-DCT [15] D9 SSIM = 0.9995、数控= 1.0 (SSIM = 0.9928,数控= 0.9947μ= 0,var = 0.0005) SSIM = 0.9997,数控= 1.0 (μ= 0,var = 0.0001) (SSIM = 0.9996,数控= 0.9984σ= 0.6,9×9) SSIM = 0.9997,数控= 1.0 (QF = 90) SSIM = 0.9002,数控= 0.9003 (CR = 10) SSIM = 1.0、数控= 1.0 (50%) - - - - - -
DWT-DCT [16] 丽娜 - - - - - - 数量= 0.0869 (0.0008) 数量= 0.0615 (0.005) 数量= 0.0869 (3×3,0.9) 数量= 0.1660 (QF = 20) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
DCT-DWT [17] 狒狒 - - - - - - 数控= 0.9982(为比例因子= 80) 数控= 0.9530(为比例因子= 80) - - - - - - 数控= 0.9994(为比例因子= 80) - - - - - - - - - - - - 数控= 0.8669(为比例因子= 80)
DWT-SVD [18] 胡椒 - - - - - - 数控= 0.9438 数控= 0.9139 - - - - - - 数控= 1.0000 - - - - - - - - - - - - 数控= 1.0000 (90°)