研究文章
一个智能帕金森病诊断系统基于一个混乱的细菌觅食优化增强模糊资讯的方法
表10
结果fixed-dimension multimodal基准函数(F14-F23)。
|
| F |
|
CBFO |
PSOBFO |
拍频振荡器 |
足总 |
平安险 |
英航 |
达 |
算法 |
|
| F14 |
Avg |
9.83 e + 00 |
3.11 e + 00 |
2.96 e + 00 |
1.82 e + 00 |
1.04 e + 00 |
4.53 e + 00 |
1.30 e + 00 |
4.41 e + 00 |
| Stdv |
4.51 e + 00 |
1.71 e + 00 |
2.22 e + 00 |
8.42 e-01 |
1.56 e-01 |
3.91 e + 00 |
6.96 e-01 |
3.20 e + 00 |
| 排名 |
8 |
5 |
4 |
3 |
1 |
7 |
2 |
6 |
|
| F15 |
Avg |
4.33 e-04 |
9.49 e-04 |
6.24 e-04 |
2.85 e 03 |
7.44 e-04 |
8.29 e 03 |
3.73 e 03 |
1.41 e 03 |
| Stdv |
1.65 e-04 |
3.00 e-04 |
2.25 e-04 |
4.71 e 03 |
1.41 e-04 |
1.35 e-02 |
5.95 e 03 |
4.04 e-04 |
| 排名 |
1 |
4 |
2 |
6 |
3 |
8 |
7 |
5 |
|
| F16 |
Avg |
-1.03 e + 00 |
-1.03 e + 00 |
-1.03 e + 00 |
-1.03 e + 00 |
-1.03 e + 00 |
-1.03 e + 00 |
-1.03 e + 00 |
-1.03 e + 00 |
| Stdv |
5.23 e-06 |
1.60 e-04 |
7.96 e-06 |
3.36 e-09 |
2.55 e-08 |
8.94 e-04 |
3.47 e-06 |
2.49 e 03 |
| 排名 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
|
| F17 |
Avg |
3.98 e-01 |
3.98 e-01 |
3.98 e-01 |
3.98 e-01 |
3.98 e-01 |
3.98 e-01 |
3.98 e-01 |
3.99 e-01 |
| Stdv |
2.24 e-06 |
4.80 e-05 |
2.02 e-06 |
1.76 e-09 |
6.28 e-09 |
5.45 e-04 |
1.84 e-07 |
1.65 e 03 |
| 排名 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
|
| F18 |
Avg |
3.00 e + 00 |
3.01 e + 00 |
3.00 e + 00 |
3.00 e + 00 |
3.00 e + 00 |
3.10 e + 00 |
3.00 e + 00 |
3.24 e + 00 |
| Stdv |
2.00 e-04 |
6.53 e 03 |
3.13 e-04 |
2.59 e-08 |
1.60 e-06 |
8.65 e-02 |
6.09 e-07 |
3.61 e-01 |
| 排名 |
1 |
6 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
6 |
1 |
8 |
|
| F19 |
Avg |
-3.86 e + 00 |
-3.86 e + 00 |
-3.86 e + 00 |
-3.86 e + 00 |
-3.86 e + 00 |
-3.83 e + 00 |
-3.86 e + 00 |
-3.84 e + 00 |
| Stdv |
4.86 e-04 |
4.56 e 03 |
5.87 e-04 |
1.03 e-09 |
2.38 e-06 |
2.49 e-02 |
1.16 e 03 |
2.10 e-02 |
| 排名 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
8 |
1 |
7 |
|
| F20 |
Avg |
-3.29 e + 00 |
-3.24 e + 00 |
-3.27 e + 00 |
-3.28 e + 00 |
-3.31 e + 00 |
-2.89 e + 00 |
-3.25 e + 00 |
-2.71 e + 00 |
| Stdv |
2.41 e-02 |
2.38 e-02 |
2.48 e-02 |
6.10 e-02 |
6.06 e 03 |
1.31 e-01 |
1.01 e-01 |
3.54 e-01 |
| 排名 |
2 |
6 |
4 |
3 |
1 |
7 |
5 |
8 |
|
| F21 |
Avg |
-6.03 e + 00 |
-1.01 e + 01 |
-9.80 e + 00 |
-7.92 e + 00 |
-1.01 e + 01 |
-4.64 e + 00 |
-6.61 e + 00 |
-3.67 e + 00 |
| Stdv |
9.74 e-01 |
4.27 e-02 |
1.28 e + 00 |
3.47 e + 00 |
1.30 e-01 |
2.43 e + 00 |
2.62 e + 00 |
1.31 e + 00 |
| 排名 |
6 |
1 |
3 |
4 |
1 |
7 |
5 |
8 |
|
| ——F22 |
Avg |
-6.45 e + 00 |
-1.01 e + 01 |
-1.02 e + 01 |
-9.89 e + 00 |
-1.02 e + 01 |
-5.03 e + 00 |
-7.35 e + 00 |
-4.33 e + 00 |
| Stdv |
1.22 e + 00 |
9.60 e-01 |
9.61 e-01 |
1.94 e + 00 |
4.87 e-01 |
2.93 e + 00 |
2.98 e + 00 |
1.67 e + 00 |
| 排名 |
6 |
3 |
1 |
4 |
1 |
7 |
5 |
8 |
|
| F23 |
Avg |
-6.91 e + 00 |
-9.73 e + 00 |
-9.98 e + 00 |
-1.05 e + 01 |
-1.02 e + 01 |
-5.36 e + 00 |
-6.35 e + 00 |
-4.42 e + 00 |
| Stdv |
1.30 e + 00 |
1.82 e + 00 |
1.63 e + 00 |
1.07 e-06 |
4.94 e-01 |
2.90 e + 00 |
3.36 e + 00 |
1.33 e + 00 |
| 排名 |
5 |
4 |
3 |
1 |
2 |
7 |
6 |
8 |
|
| 秩和 |
32 |
32 |
21 |
25 |
13 |
59 |
34 |
60 |
| 平均排名 |
3.2 |
3.2 |
2.1 |
2.5 |
1.3 |
5.9 |
3.4 |
6 |
| 整体排名 |
4 |
4 |
2 |
3 |
1 |
7 |
6 |
8 |
|
|
